Photo: Simon Law from Montréal, QC, Canada · CC BY-SA 2.0White Elephant / Friends
Rubber chicken
The poultry department has a noise complaint.
For the person who always volunteers to open first. Pick a squeaking model if the sound is part of the joke and check the length before wrapping it.
Example pictured. Available styles and sellers vary.
Paid link. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.